tomewing:
“it’s not just a disparity in opinions, it’s…this really extreme disparity in basic assumptions about her place in pop culture. It’s what she’s perceived to stand for as well as her actual material. On the one hand, people dismissing her, her voice, her diva eccentricities as totally worthless; on the other, people who consider her the defining voice and greatest pop star of the past couple of decades.”
— Lex on Mariah C
Butbutbut….
Isn’t that true of every major pop star? I think Br. pop lovers tend to ignore the disdain for, say, Britney or Madonna or Kylie, etc. in a way that they haven’t for Mariah, probably because, as Tom notes, she doesn’t have much chart traction in the UK.
For Americans (OK, for me), the maundering on about how Real Pop Music died in the 80s, or the 70s, or the 60s, by people who fancy themselves devotees of pop music, forms a kind of omnipresent backdrop to all discourse on modern pop.